Posted inHead To Head

HEAD-TO-HEAD: Blackrock versus Schroders

FSA compares two UK equity products: the BlackRock GF United Kingdom Fund and the Schroder ISF UK Equity Fund.
by Thomas Blott

123456

Performance

Despite the recent macro headwinds in the UK following sterling’s collapse, the FTSE index has actually outperformed year to date, although active managers have had a tough time, particularly those with large exposures outside the UK.

BlackRock has fared worse, delivering a return of -24.41% compared with -20.2% for Schroders and a sector average of -14.27%. BlackRock has been particularly hurt by its exposure to US growth equities.

However, BlackRock has fared better out of the two on a historical basis and has generally outperformed the benchmark, which Poole attributes to its focus on growth stocks.

“Its growth bias did result in some higher volatility, but good returns left a solid Sharpe ratio. Stock selection has been the key driver of performance, reflective of the bottom-up stock picking process,” he said.

In contrast, Schroders has been modestly behind the index, but this masquerades periods of strong outperformance, Poole noted.

Schroders’ volatility is 29.9%, which compares with a sector average of 25.83%. BlackRock fared a bit better than the index with volatility of 25.22%.

Discrete calendar year performance

Fund/Sector

YTD*

2021

2020

2019

2018
BlackRock

-24.41%

14.27%

4.32%

23.15%

-10.77%
Schroders -20.2%

-12.72%

-17.48%

13.3%

-9.14%
Equities – United Kingdom -14.27 -15.86%

-8.7%

18.48%

 -11.43%
Source: FE Fundinfo. Annual returns in US dollars. *1 Jan 2022 – 23 Sep 2022

123456

Related Stories

FSA SPY

The FSA Spy market buzz – 4 April 2025

BNY Mellon IM’s conversion; Elusive libertarian investing dream; Eastspring and Vontobel on tariffs; Wisdom of Larry Fink; Has the EU finally seen sense? Price of admission and much more.

Part of the Mark Allen Group.